Tags
American Empire, American Federalism, Calexit, California Independence, Great Britain, Jim Langcuster
I never thought 35 years ago that I world evince any sympathy for eastern German identity. Yet, I, as a Southerner, could relate to this account at a basic level. We, somewhat like the eastern Germans vis-a-vis the former West Germans, have always served as the foils of American national identity.
We can prattle on all we want about American identity, but it always has sought to impose something that really is unattainable: a common identity on a continental-sized polity.
The Framers perceived the Federal Union simply as a means of providing mutual support and protection to thirteen separate republics who constituted 13 distinct cultural communities representing populations drawn from very distinct regions of the British Isles and even the German Palatinate. Those templates were set long before the Revolution and persist today – I am happy to acknowledge in increasingly obstreporous forms.
The fact that there are vocal and growing secessionist movements encompassing both ends of the political spectrum – Calexit and Texit – and secessionist sentiment now comprises sizeable pluralities in every region of the country only attests to the fact that Jefferson was right when he argued that this continent likely would be better off comprised of smaller republics sharing a measure of cultural and political affinity.
I have got to concede that I was heartened today reading an article on Scottish nationalism, wherein the writer asserted: “You can call me ‘British’ until you’re blue in the face, but that doesn’t make “British” a thing.”


